Appendix B
A UBIQUITOUS POLLUTANT
Martin Graham
Memorandum No. UCB/ERL M00/55
28 October 2000
Electronics Research Laboratory
College of Engineering
A Ubiquitous Pollutant
Martin Graham
Professor Emeritus
ABSTRACT
University of California, Berkeley
94720
Electrical Engineering and Computer Sciences Department
University of California, Berkeley
High frequency voltages present on the electrical power wires in homes, offices, schools and factories should be considered a potential pollutant. An inexpensive and simple to use instrument is described for measuring these voltages.
The letter of May 4, 1999, by Kenneth Olden which accompanied the NIEHS Report on Health Effects from Exposure to Power-Line Frequency Electric and Magnetic Fields (1) contains the following paragraph:
The lack of connection between the human data and the experimental data (animal and mechanistic) severely complicates the interpretation of these results. The human data are in the "right" species, are tied to "real life" exposures and show some consistency that is difficult to ignore. This assessment is tempered by the observation that given the weak magnitude of these increased risks, some other factor of common source of error could explain these findings. However, no consistent explanation other than exposure to ELF-EMF has been identified.
This report suggests that the "some other factor" is high frequency currents, i.e., much higher frequency than the power line frequency. High frequency voltage can cause currents to flow in humans by direct contact, or by
capacitive coupling. The effects on humans will depend on the magnitude, wave
form, duration, and path taken through the body. The voltage causing these
currents should be considered a pollutant.
The presence of a pollutant is often obscured by the presence of much larger
quantities of non-pollutants. Low level high frequency voltages are often
obscured by the large power frequency voltages, but low level high frequency
voltage compared to the power line voltage does not imply that they do not cause
detrimental health effects in humans.
It is always a problem as to where to measure a pollutant such as high
frequency electric fields. An instrument has been developed to do a very simple
measurement. The measured voltage is that present at the standard household
electrical outlet. A filter (Figure 1) is used to remove the power line
frequency and its harmonics. The remaining voltage is applied to an RMS digital
voltmeter. The frequencies that are measured are determined by the filter and
the characteristics of the meter. The FLUKE 79 III meter responds to frequencies
above 10,000 Hz. The voltage amplitude measured will be that present on wires
and electrical equipment in that home, office, school or factory. (2) The
amount capacitively coupled to a human will depend on many variables, but a
larger voltage at the outlet will result in larger currents in the humans. The
high frequency voltage originates in modern electrical equipment, particularly
high efficiency electrical equipment. The level of this high frequency voltage
will vary with what electrical equipment is on at that location and with the
time of day, due to the varying load on the electrical utility system which also
contributes to this pollution.
Experiments are being performed to improve the design of this instrument and
the interpretation of the readings.
If the effect on humans is caused by the high frequency voltages and
currents, it would be important that the experiments with 60 Hz voltages and
currents use voltages and currents that are not contaminated with these high
frequencies.
(1) NIEHS Report on Health Effects from Exposure to Power-Line Frequency Electric and Magnetic Fields. Prepared in Response to the 1992 Energy Policy Act (PL 102-486, Section 2118), National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences, National Institutes of Health Publication No. 99-4493.
(2) Exploratory measurements of this voltage varied from tens of millivolts to hundreds of millivolts. The voltage induced by a two milligauss 60 Hz magnetic field passing through a one square meter area is less than 0.1 millivolt.
[1] Donald G. Fink and H. Wayne Beaty, editors. Standard Handbook for Electrical Engineers, 13th Edition, McGraw-Hill, 1993.
[2] Charles Polk and Eliot Postow, editors. Handbook of Biological Effects of Electromagnetic Fields, 2nd Edition, CRC Press, 1996.
[3] J. Patrick Reilly, Applied Bioelectricity: From Electrical Stimulation to Electropathology. Springer-Verlag New York, Inc., 1998.